Sire Profitability at Magic Millions 2020

Tara Madgwick - Sunday Jan 19

Magic Millions 2020 has been well covered but we always find it interesting to take a look at the sires that returned the most profit for their supporters in terms of multiple of fee and straight profit.

Below is the Sire Profitability List Top 20  sorted by multiple of fee – this one highlights cheaper sires that delivered a good return.


Turning 20 this year, Rosemont Stud’s Starcraft topped the list by multiple of fee which is really not that surprising.

Starcraft is a great value sire that can still get a good result in the sale ringFor a stallion of his quality that can get a Group I winner and seriously good types for the sale ring, Starcraft  is priced well below what he should actually be worth if fees were set on merit rather than often fickle market forces.

His three yearlings sold were all colts and his result was flattered by the inclusion of the full brother to his champion son Star Witness that made $320,000, but how good a result was that for B2B Thoroughbreds who bred and sold this cracking colt from Leone Chiara.

Leone Chiara has been to loads of expensive stallions during her stud career – Elusive Quality ($137,500), Bernardini (USA) ($55,000) , Medaglia D’Oro (USA) (twice for $88,000 and $77,000), Sepoy (twice for $66,000) and Sebring (twice for $60,500 and $66,000), but in returning to the bargain priced sire that made her a success in the first place has hit a home run in the sale ring.

For the record she has a filly to follow by Starcraft and was covered by him again last spring.

No Nay Never is an interesting one as he’s now one of Europe’s most exciting young sires and priced at Coolmore Ireland at a fee of 175,000 euros, but back in 2017 when these yearlings were conceived you could go to him here for just $11,000.

Off that fee and given what he’s done so far it would be almost impossible not to make money on No Nay Never in the sale ring this year, although that will change if his success is not replicated in Australia in the next 12 months.

No Nay Never

No Nay Never was the leading European First Season Sire of 2018 so is entitled to get two year-old winners and if there’s nothing of note here for him come the end of July, we may not see him come back here given the disparity in fee between Northern and Southern Hemisphere ($44,000 in 2019).

Below is the Sire Profitability List Top 20 sorted by straight profit– this one highlights expensive sires that were worth the big investment in fee. It should be noted Fastnet Rock stood for a private fee in 2017 so is not taken into calculation.


Yarraman Park’s I Am Invincible started his stud career topping the previous list above as a cheap sire punching above his weight, but he’s now moved across to be the best of the expensive stallions in delivering plenty of bang for buck.

I Am Invincible was the leading sire at MM 2020  by average and also in terms of straight profit from feeFor those breeders who paid $247,500 to visit I Am Invincible in 2019, they will be hoping it’s onwards and upwards, but the reality does not always unfold quite that like that.

The mighty Redoute’s Choice had a service fee peak of $330,000 in the years of 2006 and 2007, so yearlings conceived from those record fee years hit sale rings in 2009 and 2010.

For those of us who remember what the world was like post GFC, 2009 was the year the Inglis Easter average dropped from $285,637 to $177,710 and dropped again the next year to $161,150.

Redoute’s Choice was still the leading sire by average in both of those pain filled years and did produce 10 individual million dollar plus yearlings during this time at Inglis and MM combined, but his average dropped sharply leaving many vendors barely covering costs with many forced to sell for a fraction of fee just to survive.

But enough of that depressing history lesson, 2020 has started well and there is nothing not to like about what we’ve seen so far!

 

Advertisment
More Reading...
Remembering Northerly – The Greatest Caulfield Cup Winner This Century
It's Caulfield Cup week, and what better moment to revisit the life and times of one of the greatest - if not the greatest - Caulfield Cup winner of the modern era.
2027 Inglis Classic Sire Break Up and Vendor Representation
The 2027 Inglis Classic Yearling Sale is now online with 760 yearlings which is down slightly on last year and there is a significant change in the vendor list with Yulong upping their presence at Riverside Stables to be the leading vendor.
Ladies Pro Takes Listed Jungle Mist Classic First Up
Showing a devasting late turn of foot to capture the Listed WATC Jungle Mist Classic (1200m) at Ascot on Saturday, trainers Grant and Alana Williams look to have an exciting mare on their hands after D’Argento’s Ladies Pro has now reeled off three consecutive stakes victories.
Family Search on Upcoming Sales - Shadhavar
With the 2027 Magic Millions and Inglis Classic Yearling Sales now added to the Breednet Sales Centre it’s a good time to get used to Family Search allowing you to find any yearling from the family of a selected horse.
Cross Legend a Blue Hen in the Making
The Prime Thoroughbreds owners were not the only people cheering Shadhavar to victory in the Group I MRC CF Orr Stakes on Saturday.
Breeding To Win - G1 CF Orr Stakes
The last Autumn running of the CF Orr Stakes in 2025 closed a long chapter when Another Wil narrowly denied Mr Brightside consecutive victories and the historic first running of the “new” race in November last year had a worthy winner in race favourite Jimmysstar, who is back to defend his title.
G1 CF Orr Stakes - An Old Race in a New Time Slot
Four days of Flemington action are behind us for another year, and what a grand feast of horse racing it was - now Melbourne’s carnival continues with the second running of the MRC's time-honoured G1 CF Orr Stakes, in its new place on the racing calendar.
Oscar Primed for Another G1 Winterbottom - Half-Sister for MM 27
Comeback sprinter Oscar's Fortune produced a gutsy performance to claim a first up win in the G3 Colonel Reeves (1100m) at Ascot and signal that he's ready for another crack at the upcoming G1 Winterbottom Stakes.
Sires With Winners - Saturday November 14
Here is the full list of 111 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Winning Return for NZ Derby Hero
Cambridge trainers Roger James and Robert Wellwood have plenty to look forward to with their three-year-old team, despite narrowly missing Group One honours at Riccarton on Saturday.